No internet connection
  1. Home

Comments for https://ctrader.com/products/4333

By system
    2026-05-22 18:17:46.868Z

    Comments for: https://ctrader.com/products/4333

    Add Comment
    • 2 comments
    1. A
      algo_expert
        2026-05-22 18:17:46.937Z

        Hello Firat,

        Market State Engine has a very interesting institutional-style concept. The idea of combining intermarket analysis, USD pressure, liquidity behavior, and market regime detection into a lightweight HUD is much more advanced than most standard retail indicators.

        The minimalist presentation is also clean and visually well designed.

        During testing, however, the indicator could not fully activate its analytical engine and remained stuck on:

        “Waiting for symbol data...”

        This appears to be related to broker symbol compatibility. On Spotware Demo, instruments are named differently (for example “US TECH 100” instead of “USTEC”), so the indicator may currently depend on exact symbol naming.

        For usability, it would help to add:

        automatic broker symbol detection
        alias mapping support
        clearer setup diagnostics
        broker compatibility fallback logic
        validation messages inside the HUD

        The core macro/intermarket idea is strong and has real potential. With improved symbol handling and setup reliability, this could become a very useful market-context tool for discretionary and macro traders.

        Reply
        1. Ffirat_aslan
            2026-05-27 01:20:19.637Z

            Hello,

            Thank you for the detailed review and for the constructive feedback.

            You were correct about the initial issue. The earlier version had broker-symbol compatibility limitations, especially on Spotware Demo where instruments can use different names such as “US TECH 100” instead of “USTEC”.

            This has now been improved in the latest update.

            The new version includes:

            • automatic broker symbol detection
            • manual symbol override inputs for NAS100, SPX500, and GOLD
            • expanded alias mapping for FX, gold, NAS100, and SPX500
            • clearer HUD messages when a symbol cannot be detected
            • data-readiness and synchronization diagnostics inside the HUD
            • improved fallback logic for broker compatibility
            • improved conflict diagnostics
            • better conviction calibration for Risk Expansion

            The indicator should no longer remain silently stuck on “Waiting for symbol data...” without showing the exact reason.

            If possible, I would kindly ask you to test the latest version again and reconsider the rating based on the updated broker-compatibility and diagnostic improvements.

            Your feedback was useful and directly helped improve the tool.

            Best regards,
            Firat

            Reply